© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMap

Find your next fishing spot in New City, NY

Find unique fishing spots, catch locations and more on Fishbrain

Search for a species…


Check out the best fishing spots in New City, New York. Anglers have logged in Fishbrain over 41,941 catches for Largemouth bass, 5,868 catches for Bluegill, 5,418 catches for Smallmouth bass and many more species in the New City area.

Use Fishbrain to view local fishing regulations, read reviews of local fishing spots, and learn what lures are most successful in New City. Become a Pro subscriber to see when and where fish are being caught and logged in Fishbrain. Whether you use the free version of Fishbrain or upgrade to Fishbrain Pro, you can find a diverse range of successful fishing spots in New City, and get tips on how to increase your fishing success!

Local weather





Map of Holts Ice Pond© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMap
Good Bass Pond but NO FISHING!
Avatar of richpoinvil

I caught a bass there yesterday and just after that, a person that said they own the lake and the parking lot drove up and told me I cannot fish there. I think he owns the Lakeside Diner. He was not rude but It was a short conversation because he wanted to keep his distance (COVID). He said he didn't want any fish taken from the lake. I said I only catch and release. He still said no. BTW, there are 2 no fishing signs that cannot be seen after the late spring bushes grow in. The shoreline on the South Side of the Lake is pretty littered. Many seem to stop by to smoke pot in their cars.

Recent catches in New City, NY

Places to catch Bluegill in New City, NY

Anglers find these spots highly rated for catching Bluegill

Places to catch Smallmouth bass in New City, NY

Anglers find these spots highly rated for catching Smallmouth bass
Map of Indian Pond© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMap
Not like it used to be...
Avatar of thornton-c

I had my first experience with fishing at this pond. At one point there were a few species like blue gill; Lmb, smb even the occasional koi. After the park revamp the pumps aren't running and the only thing you'll find it turtles there were abandoned by there owners.

Catch map cta for sign up

Download Fishbrain app for the best fishing spots in your area

15 million catch locations, advanced fishing maps and depth charts from Navionics- all the fishing intel you need to start fish smarter and catch more.

Fishing regulations in New City

Loading regulations for the selected species...

Regulations for

41°09′15.5″N 73°59′27.2″W

Improve your fishing with Fishbrain Pro

Make your fishing dreams come true today and tomorrow

Learn more about Pro