Check out the best fishing spots in New Castle, New York. Anglers using Fishbrain have logged: 40,902 catches for Largemouth bass, 7,141 catches for Bluegill, 6,377 catches for Striped bass, 5,320 catches for Smallmouth bass, 3,341 catches for Black crappie, 3,003 catches for Yellow perch Use Fishbrain to view local fishing regulations, read reviews of local fishing spots, and learn what lures are most successful in New Castle. Become a Pro subscriber to see when and where fish are being caught and logged in Fishbrain. Whether you use the free version of Fishbrain or upgrade to Fishbrain Pro, you can find a diverse range of successful fishing spots in New Castle, and get tips on how to increase your fishing success!
Free trial available
I caught a bass there yesterday and just after that, a person that said they own the lake and the parking lot drove up and told me I cannot fish there. I think he owns the Lakeside Diner. He was not rude but It was a short conversation because he wanted to keep his distance (COVID). He said he didn't want any fish taken from the lake. I said I only catch and release. He still said no. BTW, there are 2 no fishing signs that cannot be seen after the late spring bushes grow in. The shoreline on the South Side of the Lake is pretty littered. Many seem to stop by to smoke pot in their cars.
Overall for its size it’s probably one of the best body’s of water to fish I’ve found for bass and for how little they are damn do they fight and hit hard here they def need to start taking out the baby dink’s to allow for the other bass to get bigger soon cause as you can see some have been bigger than others but there is for sure competition for food at this point although every bass I’ve caught here is very healthy I have yet to come across one sickly skinny fish