Map

Mystery Pond

Fishing spots, fishing reports, and regulations in

New York, United States

4.3·51 catches

Top fish species at Mystery Pond

App Section

Check which species have trophy potential in Mystery Pond

Mystery Pond fishing reports

fish catches icon
recently logged catches
Loading...

Channel catfish

length · weight

fish catches icon
recently logged catches
Loading...

Greengill hybrid

8 in · 6 oz

fish catches icon
recently logged catches
Loading...

Largemouth bass

length · weight

fish catches icon
recently logged catches
Loading...

Channel catfish

13 in · 1 lb

fish catches icon
recently logged catches
Loading...

Bluegill

9 in · 1 lb

fish catches icon
recently logged catches
Loading...

Greengill hybrid

9 in · 1 lb

Fishbrain
More catches in the app...

Continue browsing catches and catch locations in the Fishbrain app

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

General info

Mystery Pond is a lake located in Erie County, New York, United States. It is most popular for fishing Black bullhead, Brown bullhead, and Largemouth bass.

Location

42°44′38.6″N 78°42′8.5″W
Directions

When are Largemouth Bass biting on Mystery Pond?

Learn what time of year and day to go fishing at Mystery Pond. Download Fishbrain today to look for new fishing spots, scout new fishing access, or prep for your next trip.

Bite time image

Fishing regulations at Mystery Pond, NY

Disclaimer: Always check local fishing regulations, water access rights and land ownership before fishing, regardless of any catches logged in that area by the Fishbrain community. Fishbrain has mapped millions of acres of government-owned land across the USA to help you identify potential fishing access, but you are responsible for ensuring compliance with all legal requirements.

Fishing regulations in New York can change throughout the year. Make sure to check this page before fishing for the most up to date rules and regulations for the current season. Local regulations govern when you can fish, the max size of the fish you can keep, how many fish you can keep, and more.

Regulations for top species

License Icon
Local laws and licenses

New York fishing license

Get license

Reviews of Mystery Pond

4.3
Loading...

3 ratings

5
4
3
2
1
Top reviews

Cities nearby

Orchard Park

2.3 miles away

Aurora

3.3 miles away

Billington Heights

4.9 miles away

North Boston

6.0 miles away

Elma

6.4 miles away

West Seneca

6.9 miles away

Hamburg

7.9 miles away

Lackawanna

8.4 miles away

Wanakah

10.2 miles away

Sloan

11.2 miles away

Cheektowaga

11.6 miles away

Depew

11.6 miles away

Lancaster

11.9 miles away

Town Line

12.1 miles away

Buffalo

13.2 miles away

Strykersville

13.4 miles away

Highland-on-the-Lake

14.5 miles away

Williamsville

15.2 miles away

Harris Hill

15.9 miles away

Eggertsville

16.2 miles away

Springville

16.4 miles away

Evans

16.7 miles away

Kenmore

17.5 miles away

Angola on the Lake

18.8 miles away

Anything missing or inaccurate?

Suggest changes to improve what we show.

Suggest changes

FAQ about Mystery Pond fishing

Mystery Pond is a lake located in Erie County, New York, United States. Its coordinates are:
42°44′38.6″N 78°42′8.5″W
.
Find the best fishing spots on Mystery Pond by looking at where other anglers have caught fish. This can easily be done in the where it is also possible to see big fish potential and how good fishing is right now along with Garmin® depth maps.
The most common species in Mystery Pond are:
The latest Mystery Pond fishing reports are:
According to fishing regulations at Mystery Pond, some of the species in season this May include: Rainbow trout, Northern pike, Striped bass, Brown trout, and Walleye. For full details on other species — including bag limits, minimum and maximum size limits, and seasonal closures — download the .

Fishing in New York requires a valid state fishing license for anglers. Options include resident and non-resident, annual, daily, and lifetime licenses, available online or at licensed agents statewide.

In New York, no fishing license is required for anglers under 16. Residents 70 and older qualify for a discounted license. A few other exceptions worth knowing:

  • Free fishing days — most states designate 1–2 weekends a year where anyone can fish without a license

  • Tribal waters — tribal members fishing on tribal land operate under separate tribal regulations

  • Private ponds — landowners fishing their own water typically don't need a license

Non-residents usually pay more for a license than residents. Some species also require an extra stamp or endorsement on top of your base license.

Get license
App Section
Download Fishbrain and fish smarter
Unlimited access to the best fishing spot finder in the game. Get all the fishing intel you need to start catching more, and bigger, fish.

Free trial available

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...