/-72.8743,40.7949,10,0.00,0.00/600x250?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
New York, United States
Fishing in Shirley, New York, United States
- United States
- New York
- Shirley
Find the top species to fish in Shirley
Current weather for Shirley
Read about Shirley
Check out the best fishing spots in Shirley, New York. Anglers using Fishbrain have logged: 8,578 catches for Largemouth bass, 5,119 catches for Striped bass, 3,505 catches for Bluefish, 3,047 catches for Summer flounder, 1,541 catches for Bluegill, 1,382 catches for Black sea bass Use Fishbrain to view local fishing regulations, read reviews of local fishing spots, and learn what lures are most successful in Shirley. Become a Pro subscriber to see when and where fish are being caught and logged in Fishbrain. Whether you use the free version of Fishbrain or upgrade to Fishbrain Pro, you can find a diverse range of successful fishing spots in Shirley, and get tips on how to increase your fishing success!
Fishing regulations in Shirley
Active fishing spots in Shirley this season
/-73.227202,40.663856,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Great South Bay
601 logged catches last three months
/-72.950584,41.059778,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Long Island Sound
New York, United States
344 logged catches last three months
/-73.271139,40.633269,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Fire Island Inlet
New York, United States
142 logged catches last three months
/-73.195904,40.60689,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Town of Islip Coast
New York, United States
94 logged catches last three months
/-73.377801,40.920068,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Huntington Bay
New York, United States
88 logged catches last three months
/-73.343675,40.589706,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Town of Babylon Coast
New York, United States
86 logged catches last three months
/-73.232299805,41.142601013,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Ash Creek
Connecticut, United States
83 logged catches last three months
/-72.476917,40.850929,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Shinnecock Bay
New York, United States
69 logged catches last three months
/-73.122907,40.827403,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Lake Ronkonkoma
New York, United States
35 logged catches last three months
/-73.053398132,41.214298248,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Milford Harbor
Connecticut, United States
32 logged catches last three months
Download Fishbrain and fish smarter
Unlimited access to the best fishing spot finder in the game. Get all the fishing intel you need to start catching more, and bigger, fish.
Free trial available
Places to catch Largemouth bass in Shirley, NY
/-72.888367,40.80876,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap South Haven Pond
New York, United States
828 logged catches
/-73.225141,40.835596,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Stump Pond
New York, United States
774 logged catches
/-72.934783,40.88338,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Artist Lake
New York, United States
839 logged catches
/-73.328927,40.725479,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Elda Lake
New York, United States
306 logged catches
/-73.328392,40.711069,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Southards Pond
New York, United States
393 logged catches
/-73.341454,40.735849,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Belmont Lake
New York, United States
382 logged catches
/-72.967192,40.888298,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Pine Lake
New York, United States
413 logged catches
/-72.731003,40.910594,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Peconic Lake
New York, United States
373 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Lake Ronkonkoma
New York, United States
241 logged catches
/-73.194336,40.847353,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Millers Pond
New York, United States
233 logged catches
/-73.201526,40.733122,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Knapps Lake
New York, United States
176 logged catches
/-73.13921,40.84487,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Gibbs Pond
New York, United States
226 logged catches
/-72.93808,40.844736,10,0.00,0.00/600x450?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap My favorite lake to fish in Long island
%2Fzrsymclkn8i7woa2i3esz1b3nixe&w=48&q=75){kind=small}
I HAVE BEEN FISHING THIS LAKE SINCE I WAS 18 YEARS OLD USE TO COME OUT HERE WHEN I LIVED IN QUEENS AND THIS LAKE HAS CHANGED SO MUCH IN A GOOD WAY I LOVE THE TROUT FISHING IN THIS LAKE ESPECIALLY IN THE FALL WINTER AND SPRING TIME THIS LAKE ALSO HAS MY PB LARGEMOUTH I CAUGHT AT 7 LBS 2 OUNCES WHICH I CAUGHT LIVE LINING A BLUEGILL NO EXPCETIONS I HAVE BAD FISHING DAYS THERE AS WELL. WELL I HOPE TGIS REVIEW WILL BE HELPFUL FOR ANYONE WHI LOVES THE OUTDOORS LIKE I DO TIGHT LINES EVERYONE
Places to catch Striped bass in Shirley, NY
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Long Island Sound
New York, United States
2158 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Ash Creek
Connecticut, United States
1082 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Great South Bay
New York, United States
731 logged catches
/-73.108398438,41.169300079,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Housatonic River
Connecticut, United States
545 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Town of Babylon Coast
New York, United States
460 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Fire Island Inlet
New York, United States
308 logged catches
/-72.917856,40.685381,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Town of Brookhaven Coast
New York, United States
264 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Huntington Bay
New York, United States
234 logged catches
/-72.705591,40.790271,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Moriches Bay
New York, United States
202 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Town of Islip Coast
New York, United States
215 logged catches
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Shinnecock Bay
New York, United States
192 logged catches
/-73.259447,40.936142,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Smithtown Bay
New York, United States
143 logged catches
/-72.556891,40.979096,10,0.00,0.00/600x450?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Hidden Gem
%2Favatar%2Fdefault%2Fbig&w=48&q=75){kind=small}
Boat "ramp" is decent little walk from the parking lot and only smaller boats that can be hand carried will work here, like kayaks, canoes or inflatables. Great lake for largemouth bass, pickerel and bluegills/pumpkinseeds. The bass aren't really active until the sun gets low in the summer, pickerel and panfish bite all day and some of those panfish get to be the size of a hub cap. Rainbow and brown trout fishing in fall is pretty good when the water cools down. Yellow perch and white perch are also in this lake supposedly, I have yet to catch any perch here though.
Other cities near Shirley
Other anglers checked out these waters