© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMap
Find your next fishing spot in Brookhaven, NY
Find unique fishing spots, catch locations and more on Fishbrain
Search for a species…
About
Check out the best fishing spots in Brookhaven, New York. Anglers have logged in Fishbrain over 10,097 catches for Largemouth bass, 5,891 catches for Striped bass, 3,798 catches for Bluefish and many more species in the Brookhaven area.
Use Fishbrain to view local fishing regulations, read reviews of local fishing spots, and learn what lures are most successful in Brookhaven. Become a Pro subscriber to see when and where fish are being caught and logged in Fishbrain. Whether you use the free version of Fishbrain or upgrade to Fishbrain Pro, you can find a diverse range of successful fishing spots in Brookhaven, and get tips on how to increase your fishing success!
Local weather
Weather
-
Wind
-
Trophy catches in Brookhaven, NY
Check out what local anglers are reeling in and add your trophy fish
Places to catch Largemouth bass in Brookhaven, NY
Anglers find these spots highly rated for catching Largemouth bass
/-72.888367,40.80876,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapSouth Haven Pond
791 logged catches
/-72.934783,40.88338,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapArtist Lake
New York,
United States821 logged catches
/-73.225141,40.835596,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapStump Pond
New York,
United States677 logged catches
/-73.328927,40.725479,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapElda Lake
New York,
United States296 logged catches
/-73.341454,40.735849,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapBelmont Lake
New York,
United States351 logged catches
/-73.328392,40.711069,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapSouthards Pond
New York,
United States367 logged catches
/-72.967192,40.888298,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapPine Lake
New York,
United States361 logged catches
/-73.274597168,41.158100128,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapBrowns Brook
Connecticut,
United States333 logged catches
/-72.731003,40.910594,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapPeconic Lake
New York,
United States302 logged catches
/-73.254798889,41.205101013,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapLake Mohegan
Connecticut,
United States310 logged catches
/-73.14099884,41.214385986,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapWooster Park
188 logged catches
/-73.475301,40.76008,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapPlainview Pond
31 logged catches
4.5
/-72.93808,40.844736,10,0.00,0.00/600x450?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapMy favorite lake to fish in Long island
%2Fzrsymclkn8i7woa2i3esz1b3nixe&w=48&q=75){kind=small}
I HAVE BEEN FISHING THIS LAKE SINCE I WAS 18 YEARS OLD USE TO COME OUT HERE WHEN I LIVED IN QUEENS AND THIS LAKE HAS CHANGED SO MUCH IN A GOOD WAY I LOVE THE TROUT FISHING IN THIS LAKE ESPECIALLY IN THE FALL WINTER AND SPRING TIME THIS LAKE ALSO HAS MY PB LARGEMOUTH I CAUGHT AT 7 LBS 2 OUNCES WHICH I CAUGHT LIVE LINING A BLUEGILL NO EXPCETIONS I HAVE BAD FISHING DAYS THERE AS WELL. WELL I HOPE TGIS REVIEW WILL BE HELPFUL FOR ANYONE WHI LOVES THE OUTDOORS LIKE I DO TIGHT LINES EVERYONE
Recent catches in Brookhaven, NY
Places to catch Striped bass in Brookhaven, NY
Anglers find these spots highly rated for catching Striped bass
/-72.950584,41.059778,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapLong Island Sound
New York,
United States1924 logged catches
/-73.232299805,41.142601013,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapAsh Creek
Connecticut,
United States1050 logged catches
/-73.227202,40.663856,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapGreat South Bay
New York,
United States670 logged catches
/-73.108398438,41.169300079,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapHousatonic River
Connecticut,
United States414 logged catches
/-73.343675,40.589706,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapTown of Babylon Coast
403 logged catches
/-73.271139,40.633269,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapFire Island Inlet
New York,
United States288 logged catches
/-72.917856,40.685381,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapTown of Brookhaven Coast
235 logged catches
/-72.705591,40.790271,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapMoriches Bay
New York,
United States195 logged catches
/-72.917602539,41.273399353,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapNew Haven Harbor
Connecticut,
United States216 logged catches
/-72.476917,40.850929,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapShinnecock Bay
New York,
United States164 logged catches
/-73.377801,40.920068,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapHuntington Bay
New York,
United States188 logged catches
/-73.195904,40.60689,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapTown of Islip Coast
154 logged catches
Places to catch Bluefish in Brookhaven, NY
Anglers find these spots highly rated for catching Bluefish
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapGreat South Bay
New York,
United States1061 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapLong Island Sound
New York,
United States872 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapAsh Creek
Connecticut,
United States319 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapFire Island Inlet
New York,
United States248 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapMoriches Bay
New York,
United States234 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapShinnecock Bay
New York,
United States215 logged catches
/-72.835177,40.747437,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapNarrow Bay
New York,
United States194 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapTown of Babylon Coast
107 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapNew Haven Harbor
Connecticut,
United States118 logged catches
/-72.491663,40.833731,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapPonquogue Beach
91 logged catches
/-73.259447,40.936142,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapSmithtown Bay
New York,
United States99 logged catches
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapHuntington Bay
New York,
United States93 logged catches
5.0
/-72.556891,40.979096,10,0.00,0.00/600x450?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapHidden Gem
%2Favatar%2Fdefault%2Fbig&w=48&q=75){kind=small}
Boat "ramp" is decent little walk from the parking lot and only smaller boats that can be hand carried will work here, like kayaks, canoes or inflatables. Great lake for largemouth bass, pickerel and bluegills/pumpkinseeds. The bass aren't really active until the sun gets low in the summer, pickerel and panfish bite all day and some of those panfish get to be the size of a hub cap. Rainbow and brown trout fishing in fall is pretty good when the water cools down. Yellow perch and white perch are also in this lake supposedly, I have yet to catch any perch here though.
Download Fishbrain app for the best fishing spots in your area
15 million catch locations, advanced fishing maps and depth charts from Navionics- all the fishing intel you need to start fish smarter and catch more.
Most active fishing spots in Brookhaven this season
Other anglers checked out these waters
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapGreat South Bay
New York,
United States264 logged catches last three months
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapLong Island Sound
New York,
United States258 logged catches last three months
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapSouth Haven Pond
61 logged catches last three months
/-73.49423,40.901821,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapOyster Bay
New York,
United States56 logged catches last three months
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapFire Island Inlet
New York,
United States55 logged catches last three months
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapTown of Babylon Coast
55 logged catches last three months
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapHousatonic River
Connecticut,
United States53 logged catches last three months
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapLake Mohegan
Connecticut,
United States49 logged catches last three months
/-73.464344,40.67888,10,0.00,0.00/372x261?access_token=pk.eyJ1IjoiZmlzaGJyYWluLWRldiIsImEiOiJjbDl6ZDU2amEwZXFtM29rNmI5cTV5ZGZ3In0.PEsOW8Rbc7G-mIBHpNXeGQ&logo=false&attribution=false)
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapMassapequa Reservoir
47 logged catches last three months
© Mapbox, © OpenStreetMapHuntington Bay
New York,
United States45 logged catches last three months
Fishing regulations in Brookhaven
Regulations for
40°49′55.6″N 72°57′6.5″W
Improve your fishing with Fishbrain Pro
Make your fishing dreams come true today and tomorrow